The quickest way to separate a genuine tree surgeon from someone with a chainsaw and a van is to ask three things before any work starts: proof of public liability insurance, evidence of proper chainsaw and climbing training, and a written quote that says exactly what will be done. If a contractor hesitates on any of these, or can’t produce paperwork when asked, that’s your answer. We’ve been doing this work across Dublin for over 28 years, and the jobs that go wrong almost always trace back to one of these three being skipped at the start.
Why this matters more in Dublin than people assume
Dublin has a particular mix of conditions that makes a dodgy tree job more likely to end badly than in a lot of other places. Gardens in areas like Rathmines, Drumcondra and Dun Laoghaire tend to be small, with trees growing close to boundary walls, sheds, and neighbouring houses. A lot of the mature trees we work on in Clontarf, Glasnevin and Terenure are decades old, planted when the gardens were bigger or before extensions were added, and they’re now sitting right beside a roof, a conservatory, or a party wall shared with next door.
That proximity changes everything. A crown reduction done badly on a tree six feet from a kitchen extension isn’t just an untidy job, it’s a potential insurance claim waiting to happen. If a branch comes down on a shed or a car, or a climber falls and there’s no cover, the homeowner who hired the contractor can end up liable too. We see this more often than people expect: a neighbour’s tree work goes wrong, damage spills onto the next garden, and nobody can establish who’s actually covered.
Insurance: the one thing you must see before work starts
Ask for proof of public liability insurance, and ideally employer’s liability cover if they have staff or a climbing partner working with them. A reputable operator will have no issue emailing you a copy of the certificate or showing it on site. What you’re checking for is that it’s current (not expired), and that the cover level is reasonable for the scale of the job, a large crown reduction near a house needs a different level of comfort than trimming a garden hedge.
Don’t accept “we’re insured, don’t worry about it” as an answer. Ask to see it. This is standard practice and nobody properly insured should be put out by the request. If they are, that tells you something.
Qualifications and certs: what to actually ask about
Tree work in Ireland isn’t a licensed trade the way plumbing or electrical work can be, which is exactly why so many unqualified people end up doing it. There’s no single body stopping someone buying a chainsaw and calling themselves a tree surgeon. What you want to hear is that the person doing the climbing or the chainsaw work has recognised chainsaw and aerial training (the kind of courses covering chainsaw maintenance, crosscutting, felling and aerial rescue that are standard in this trade), and ideally some formal arboriculture background rather than just time served. Ask directly: “what training do you and your crew have for climbing and chainsaw work?” A genuine tree surgeon will answer that plainly and specifically. Someone winging it will go vague or change the subject.
We’d also say this: experience matters alongside paper qualifications, not instead of them. Someone can hold a certificate and still be careless, and someone with years of hands-on work can be excellent. The point of asking is to filter out the people with neither.
Red flags we’d walk away from
Over nearly three decades doing this work, certain warning signs come up again and again on jobs we get called in to fix after someone else made a mess of them. If you spot more than one of these, get a second quote.
- No written quote, just a figure given verbally on the doorstep with no breakdown of the work.
- Reluctance or refusal to show proof of insurance when asked directly.
- Pressure to pay a large deposit or the full amount up front before any work is done.
- Cold callers after a storm, offering to do “emergency” work immediately at a knock-down rate.
- No mention of checking whether the tree is covered by a Tree Preservation Order or whether the property is in a conservation area.
- Vague answers about how debris and timber will be removed, or where it’s going.
- Topping (indiscriminately cutting the top off a tree) offered as a solution, rather than proper crown reduction or thinning carried out at the right points on the branch structure.
Planning permission and Tree Preservation Orders
Before any significant work on a tree, especially removal or heavy reduction, it’s worth checking whether a Tree Preservation Order applies, or whether the tree sits within a conservation area where extra rules can kick in. This varies property by property and the detail can change, so the right move is always to confirm the current position directly with your local authority before committing to the work. A genuine tree surgeon will raise this with you rather than just getting on with the job and hoping nobody notices.
What a proper quote should include
A quote worth trusting usually comes after someone has actually looked at the tree in person, not just gone on a phone description or a photo. It should set out what work is being done (removal, crown reduction, pollarding, or something else), how access and any nearby structures will be managed, whether stump grinding is included or separate, and what happens to the arisings (the cut timber and brash). It should also be clear about timing, since weather and access can shift a schedule in Dublin more than people expect, particularly in exposed gardens near the coast in Dun Laoghaire or Clontarf.
What pushes a quote up or down is usually access (can a van or chipper get into the garden, or does everything have to be carried out by hand), the height and condition of the tree, how close it is to buildings, wires or boundaries, and whether the timber and waste need to be removed from site. None of that can be priced sensibly without someone looking at the actual tree, which is why we’d be wary of anyone quoting a firm figure over the phone.
Getting it right the first time
We’d always say to a homeowner: don’t let the fear of a slightly higher quote push you towards the cheapest option on the table. Tree work that’s done wrong, a tree topped badly, a stump left to regrow, a climber working without proper rescue training near your roofline, tends to cost more to put right later than it would have to do properly the first time. If you’re weighing up options for a full range of tree services, from removal to pruning to hedge care, it’s worth getting more than one person out to actually look at the job before deciding.
We’ve been working on trees and hedges across Dublin for over 28 years, fully insured and qualified, and we’re happy to come out, have a proper look, and give you a straight answer on what needs doing and why. You can get in touch through our contact page whenever suits.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I check if a tree surgeon in Dublin is actually insured?
Ask them directly for a copy of their public liability insurance certificate before work starts, and check the date on it. A genuine operator will send this over by email or show it on site without any fuss. If someone avoids the question or says “don’t worry about it,” that’s a reason to look elsewhere.
Do I need planning permission to remove a tree in my Dublin garden?
It depends on the tree, whether a Tree Preservation Order applies, and whether the property is in a conservation area. This can vary from one area to the next, so confirm the current position with your local authority before any removal work, particularly for larger or older trees.
What’s the difference between a tree surgeon and someone who just cuts trees down?
A properly trained tree surgeon understands tree biology, how to prune or reduce a crown without damaging the tree’s long-term health, and how to work safely at height with the right rescue plan in place. Someone without that training might get the branch on the ground, but often leaves the tree weaker, unbalanced, or more likely to fail in future storms.
Why do some tree surgeons quote so much less than others?
A lower quote usually means something is missing, whether that’s proper insurance, qualified staff, waste disposal, or stump removal being left out entirely. It’s always worth asking what’s included before comparing figures side by side, since two quotes for the “same job” often aren’t actually the same job at all.
Should I get more than one quote before hiring a tree surgeon?
Yes, especially for larger jobs like crown reduction or removal of a mature tree. It gives you a feel for what’s reasonable for your particular tree and garden, and it’s a good way to compare how thorough each contractor is in explaining the work and checking things like Tree Preservation Orders.
What should I do after a storm if a tree on my property looks damaged?
Keep people and cars away from the area and avoid trying to assess or clear it yourself if there’s any doubt about stability. Contact a qualified tree surgeon to inspect it properly, and be wary of unsolicited callers offering immediate storm work at your door, as this is a common pressure tactic after bad weather.


